Over Half of Pakistan's Tobacco Farmers Sell Without Written Contracts, Study Finds
An IPOR survey of 1,200 farmers in Swabi, Mardan, and Charsadda reveals that 52% sell tobacco without written agreements, raising concerns about regulatory compliance and illicit trade.
Get this story and every big update first on WhatsAppFollow the around.pk English News channel — free, no spam Follow
A new study by the Institute for Public Opinion Research (IPOR) has found that 52% of tobacco farmers in Pakistan sell their crops to buyers without any direct written agreement, highlighting significant gaps in compliance with Pakistan Tobacco Board (PTB) regulations. The survey, titled 'Assessment of Tobacco-Leaf Production, Marketing and Purchasing Practices in Pakistan,' covered 1,200 farmers across Swabi, Mardan, and Charsadda, and examined purchasing agreements, pricing, payment methods, and regulatory adherence.
The findings indicate that 45% of farmers had no written purchasing agreement before planting. Under the PTB framework, tobacco purchases are subject to government-notified weighted average price requirements intended to protect farmers, and companies and dealers must meet announced purchasing quotas, including additional surplus quantities assigned by the board. The study observed considerable price disparities: farmers selling to multinational tobacco companies received an average of PKR 720 per kilogram, compared with PKR 559 from other companies and PKR 471 from dealers.
Among farmers who sold outside formal agreements and faced difficulties, 85% reported receiving offers below the official PTB price. Payment practices also raised concerns: 52% of those in non-contracted arrangements were paid in cash, and 36% received payment immediately at the time of purchase. Such practices undermine transparency and traceability, especially when tobacco is bought directly without passing through designated buying depots, pointing to a parallel gray market operating outside PTB oversight.
The study's findings raise questions about enforcement as the government works to curb illicit tobacco trade. Weak oversight at the supply chain's beginning could create opportunities for tobacco leaf to enter undocumented and potentially illicit distribution channels. IPOR Executive Director Tariq Junaid commented that gaps in compliance with existing regulations create uncertainty for farmers and increase the risk of below-market payments. 'When tobacco is traded outside formal agreements through third-party buyers, farmers face greater uncertainty and the risk of receiving prices below those prescribed by the Pakistan Tobacco Board. Stronger enforcement of existing regulations is essential to address these gaps,' he said.
The survey underscores the need for stricter enforcement of PTB regulations to protect farmers and ensure a transparent supply chain. With more than half of surveyed farmers operating without written contracts, the findings suggest that a significant portion of tobacco leaf may be flowing through informal channels, potentially undermining government efforts to regulate the sector and combat illicit trade.








