around.pk
Wednesday, 18 November 2026
☀ Karachi 25°☀ Lahore 17°☀ Islamabad 14°
Pakistan

LHC Rules Private DNA Test Cannot Override Child's Legitimacy Under Valid Marriage

The Lahore High Court has held that a privately commissioned DNA test cannot displace the legal presumption that a child born during a valid marriage is legitimate, dismissing a father's challenge to maintenance and dowry recovery orders.

around.pk·11h ago

The Lahore High Court has ruled that a privately arranged DNA test cannot override the legal presumption of legitimacy for a child born during a valid marriage, dismissing a father's petition challenging maintenance awarded to his minor son as well as an order for the recovery of dowry articles.

Justice Asad Ali Bajwa, hearing the petition filed by Usama Tahir and others against Zainab Irfan and others, held that a father cannot disown a child born while the marriage was subsisting simply by relying on a DNA test arranged outside court supervision. The court noted that the couple married on August 18, 2019, and that their son was born on April 27, 2022, during the currency of that marriage.

According to the judgment, the father had disputed paternity on the basis of a DNA report said to have been obtained from a private laboratory in the United Kingdom, which reportedly excluded him as the biological father. The court observed, however, that nothing on the record showed the test was carried out under the supervision or direction of a competent court.

The ruling turned on Article 128 of the Qanun-e-Shahadat Order, 1984, under which the birth of a child during a valid marriage creates a conclusive presumption of legitimacy, subject to exceptions provided by law. The court also weighed admissions by the father's family members during evidence that the marriage remained intact when the child was born.

It held that a privately arranged DNA report, on its own, could not displace the presumption of legitimacy protected under Article 128, and that questions of paternity must be handled cautiously, with regard for the child's dignity, privacy and emotional well-being.

The judgment further emphasised that courts are responsible not only for resolving legal disputes but also for safeguarding human dignity, particularly where the rights of minors are concerned, noting that children are entitled to privacy and protection from emotional harm even when they cannot voice their concerns.

The court stated that DNA testing in paternity disputes is a serious judicial matter that cannot be ordered simply because a party demands it or because the technology is available, adding that even where both parents consent to testing, a court must independently assess whether it serves the child's best interests.

The story so far Lahore High Court

  1. Supreme Court Clarifies Islamic Inheritance Shares, Upholds Cousin's Right to Residuary Estate
  2. Lahore High Court Upholds PMDC Fee Cap, Orders Private Medical Colleges to Refund Excess Charges
  3. Petition in Lahore High Court Challenges Flaws in Punjab's E-Challan System
  4. Lahore High Court Rules FIA Cannot Arrest Borrowers Until Banking Court Declares Wilful Default
See the full timeline →
LahoreCourts & justiceUnited KingdomHigh CourtsLahore High CourtJustice Asad Ali BajwaQanun-e-Shahadat Order, 1984

Continue the story

View all →

Read more